Reeves urges Labour MPs to back winter fuel cut

Chancellor Rachel Reeves has urged Labour MPs to back her plan to cut winter fuel payments.

More than nine million pensioners will no longer be eligible for up to £300 this winter after Ms Reeves announced the introduction of means-testing following Labour’s election win.

There are concerns dozens of Labour MPs could abstain in a vote on the policy in Parliament on Tuesday, amid worry pensioners on modest incomes may miss out this winter.

In a call for solidarity ahead of that vote, Chancellor Rachel Reeves said the blame should fall on “reckless decisions” on public finances by the Conservatives. The prime minister told journalists the government had not wanted to take the “tough decision” but it was done to help secure economic stability.

Addressing MPs at a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party on Monday evening, the chancellor told them: “We stand, we lead and we govern together”.

Ms Reeves added that she was “not immune to the arguments that many in this room have made”.

However, she said the government’s commitment to the triple lock meant the state pension had risen by around £900 compared with a year ago.

Ms Reeves added: “It is the right thing to do, to target money at a time when finances are so stretched, at people who need them most.”

Ms Reeves and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer insist the winter fuel payment cut – worth about £1.5bn – is necessary to fill an alleged £22bn “black hole” in the budget left by the previous Conservative government.

Speaking on Monday to Scottish lobby journalists Sir Keir said Labour was “elected into government on the basis of economic stability, that we would secure the foundations”.

The prime minister said he had not wanted to “inherit” such a situation but was “not prepared to walk past” it.

The Labour government has a large majority and is expected to win the vote, which has been called by the Conservative opposition, but the vote will be another early test of the prime minister’s authority..

There is speculation about a potential rebellion by at least 17 Labour MPs who signed a Commons motion describing the plans to means test the benefit as “bureaucratic and unpopular”.

One prominent rebel, Diane Abbott, told the BBC’s The World Tonight programme she “certainly won’t support” her party in Tuesday’s vote.

She said: “It’s ill-thought-out… they’re doing it to look tough and I think it’s wrong to play games at the expense of the poorest pensioners just to look tough.”

Ms Abbott has signed the Commons motion and suggested “maybe hundreds” of MPs were upset about the planned cuts and could act on that.

Sir Keir and his cabinet are standing firm, and have “agreed” on the importance of scaling back the benefit, a Downing Street spokesman said.

They said the prime minister told ministers at a cabinet meeting that “tough decisions” were necessary to fix “the foundations of our economy” and added there were no plans to give further mitigations to pensioners who lose out.

The Conservatives say Labour are exaggerating the state of the public finances to lay the ground for tax rises in the October budget.

Conservative leader Rishi Sunak accused ministers of trying to “fast-track cuts” to vital support for pensioners “to fund an inflation-busting pay rise for train drivers”.

He added that Labour MPs “must do the right thing and force the government to come clean about the impact this punishing cut will have”.

The winter fuel payment was a universal benefit, meaning it was paid to all pensioners, regardless of their income or wealth.

Think tank the Social Market Foundation was one voice arguing universal winter fuel payments meant some well-off pensioners were receiving hundreds of pounds they didn’t need to cover energy costs and would be better targeted elsewhere.

However, charities such as Age Concern said they believed two million pensioners would struggle to pay their bills and heat their homes as a result of the change.

The government estimates 9.3 million fewer pensioners will be able to claim the payment of between £200 and £300 a year.

Only those on low incomes who receive certain benefits will be eligible and the vast majority of those will only receive the winter fuel payment if they have first claimed pension credit, a state pension top-up.

The prime minister’s deputy spokesperson said the government would “continue to urge people to check their eligibility” for pension credit and to “support people in making those applications”.

The spokesperson said there had been 38,500 pension credit claims in the last five weeks.

In comparison, there had been 17,900 claims over the five weeks before Ms Reeves announced the payment would only be available to those on certain benefits in July.

The PM’s spokesperson said this was a 115% increase, but added the campaign to get pensioners to sign up was “ongoing” and there was “still more to do”.

One of those pensioners – Dave Stone, from Bournemouth – has been facing a delay with applying for pension credit since 6 February, months before planned cuts to the winter fuel payment were announced, and says the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) is now “even busier because of the latest changes”.

He applied online to claim pension credit for his aunt, following the council telling him she was eligible, and was given a six-week deadline of 19 March for a response.

He said he still does not have an answer seven months later, despite nearly 20 interactions with the team.

“Every time I gave them an extra week or two, then I would call them back after they’d missed their deadlines, and nothing much would happen,” Mr Stone told BBC Radio 4’s PM programme.

“They’ve got to the stage where they’re now even busier, because of the latest changes they can’t put anybody through to the pensions centre any more – all they can say is ‘we’ll call you back’ and of course I know [that] isn’t going to happen.”

A DWP spokesman said it had “surged additional staff” to cover the increase in pension credit calls.

Government figures had suggested there were about 800,000 households who were eligible for pension credit but did not claim it.